Files
curriculum-project-hub/docs/adr/0017-agent-session-is-provider-bound.md
T

96 lines
4.8 KiB
Markdown

# ADR 0017: Agent Runtime — Claude Code SDK via OpenRouter
## Status
Accepted.
## Context
The original ADR-0017 mandated a provider-agnostic agent layer: any
OpenAI-compatible model via OpenRouter, custom agent loop built on Vercel AI
SDK's `streamText`. The motivation was to avoid vendor lock-in.
In practice, the hand-rolled agent loop lacked capabilities that a production
agent needs: context compaction (long conversations), tool approval flows,
partial-message streaming, and a battle-tested multi-turn loop. Building these
ourselves meant re-implementing what the Claude Code SDK already provides.
The Feishu integration also proved costly to hand-roll — card schema quirks,
patch limitations, file support — each API quirk cost a round-trip.
## Decision
Adopt `@anthropic-ai/claude-agent-sdk` as the agent runtime, routed through
OpenRouter's **"Anthropic Skin"** (`https://openrouter.ai/api`).
OpenRouter exposes an Anthropic Messages API-compatible endpoint. Claude Code
SDK speaks its native protocol directly to OpenRouter — no proxy, no format
conversion. The SDK's `query()` owns the agent loop (tool dispatch, compaction,
streaming). Built-in tools (Read, Write, Bash, Glob, Grep) cover the entire
tool surface — no custom tools needed. `cph check` / `cph build` run via Bash.
The Hub `AgentSession` is provider/role/model-bound, and it must persist the
provider runtime cursor needed to continue a conversation. For Claude Code SDK,
that cursor is the `result.session_id`; store it in `AgentSession.metadata` as
`claudeSessionId` and pass it back to the next `query()` call as
`options.resume`. Role is part of the session binding because role prompts and
tool surfaces can differ even when the underlying model is the same. A Feishu
project group's active binding selects one Organization role for ordinary
messages. Switching that selection routes future messages to the selected
role's own session; it never mutates or merges provider cursors across roles.
Work freezes the selected role when accepted so queued requests cannot drift
after a later switch.
Role definitions are Organization-scoped runtime data. A role bundle selects
its default model, system prompt, tool allowlist and installed Agent skill
versions. PostgreSQL is authoritative for role composition and skill metadata;
skill bytes live in a content-addressed persistent store selected only by the
recorded SHA-256 digest. Updating a role or binding skills takes effect without
a Hub release or process restart. A change to the role's execution surface
(model, prompt, tools, selected skill content) archives its active sessions so
the next run cannot resume a provider context created under stale instructions;
label and ordering-only changes preserve conversational continuity.
Exactly one active role per Organization is the default used when a project
group is first bound. The default is configuration data, not a hard-coded role
name. Roles are selected through the Hub project console; role ids are not
public slash commands. A project participant may change the group's shared
selection only when both `agent.trigger` for the project and `role.trigger` for
the target role authorize that actor. The selection affects every participant's
future messages, while already accepted work keeps its frozen role.
Hub slash commands are a closed control-plane protocol. Unknown commands fail
explicitly and are never downgraded to Agent text. Claude SDK session commands
are invoked only through typed Hub actions. In particular, compaction resumes
the selected role session and sends the exact `/compact` prompt without
prepending Feishu context.
Environment variables:
```
ANTHROPIC_BASE_URL=https://openrouter.ai/api
ANTHROPIC_AUTH_TOKEN=<OpenRouter API key>
ANTHROPIC_API_KEY="" # must be explicitly empty
```
Model routing: `ANTHROPIC_DEFAULT_SONNET_MODEL` etc. accept OpenRouter model
IDs (e.g. `z-ai/glm-4.7`, `anthropic/claude-sonnet-4-20250514`). This gives
limited OpenRouter-level model routing, but the runtime is still Claude Agent
SDK-shaped: non-Claude models are best-effort and may not support every
Claude Code feature.
## Consequences
- Provider-agnosticism is not fully preserved. OpenRouter can route to GLM,
Claude, GPT, etc., but the runtime protocol and agent loop remain Claude
Agent SDK-bound.
- The agent loop is Claude Code SDK's (compaction, tool approval, partial
message streaming) — not hand-rolled.
- Custom tools (read_file, write_file, cph_check, cph_build) are replaced by
the SDK's built-in Read/Write/Bash/Glob/Grep.
- The SSE event format matches Claude-to-IM's expected protocol natively.
- Per-run model selection works via role→model mapping; models are OpenRouter
IDs, not Anthropic-only aliases.
- OpenRouter recommends setting Anthropic as the top-priority provider for
Claude Code; non-Anthropic models may have reduced compatibility with some
SDK features (e.g. thinking blocks).